Showing posts with label intelligent design. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intelligent design. Show all posts

Friday, March 11, 2011

Is Intelligent Design real science?



Is Intelligent Design real science?
To answer this question, first of all, we need to understand the definition of Science. What is Science? According to
Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary,the definition of science is "knowledge attained through study or practice," or "knowledge covering general truths of the operation of general laws, esp. as obtained and tested through scientific method [and] concerned with the physical world." Compare the definition of science to the concept of Intelligent design, we may have the answer for the question.
Appearing in "Judgement Day: Intelligent design on trial", Dr. Behe is a professor in the department of biological science at Lehigh university Bethlehem, Pennsylvania; he is best known as the author of "Darwin's black box", a senior fellow of the idea of Intelligent Design. He define the factor of science about Intelligent design as "observable, empirical, physical evidence from nature" and "logical inference". The two major differences between these two definitions are : Possibility of getting tested and concernation of topic. A topic that could be considered science must be tested by a scientific method.
According to Dr. Hebe, Intelligent design have never been tested and could not be tested. This factor gives Dr. Hebe a big minus point. Concernation, a topic that could be considered science must be concerned with the physical world, "Intelligent Design" is based on the thinking of the creation of all living forms designed by an unknown "Designer", " Creator", or "Greater Being". This has nothing to do with the physical world.
In conclusion, the theory is not tested and not close to reality and physical world, but that does not mean the theory is not true, which is absolutely true; it can not be proved but it may still exists. But the question here is about is it possible to consider " Intelligent Design" science, the answer is no, at least,
temporarily, it is not real science yet.


Sunday, March 6, 2011

Religion in Science class?

Many people argue whether or not the theory of Intelligent Design is a religion, and whether it should be integrated into science classes, along with the popular theory of Darwinism.

First, lets discuss the basis of Intelligent Design being either a scientific theory or a religion, worded to convince the minds of the public that it is a so-called theory. In this argument a very popular question arises- who is the intelligent designer? Some will argue it is God, or that it is a futuristic designer (where did he come from!?), or even perhaps a time traveling alien from Mars. A scientific theory has scientific evidence- not just physical evidence, but scientific. Evidence is there to support the theory at hand. Although scientific evidence has no universal definition, it is assumed that it is applicable to the subject. Scientific evidence has more leverage than physical evidence in any case. Discovering scientific evidence usually means the theory it is supporting is correct, thus making it an inductive argument. The theory of Evolution has many new-age technologies to back it up (Genetics, DNA coding, ect). However, unlike the theory of Evolution, Intelligent Design relies solely on physical identification (such as organisms seeming, or looking "too complex" for evolution to have occurred) to back it up; thus making Intelligent Design seem more like an overnight idea than a theory studied for hundreds of years.


So why should we, or shouldn't we, have it taught in science classes? 

One of the key fundamentals of today's technology, today's medicine, and today's biology, is the theory of evolution. Why should we disregard that and introduce a new "scientific" theory with no evidence? Without the theory of evolution, we wouldn't be able to produce new vaccines, or antibiotics, as we would lack the study of how our genes and cells have changed overtime, and our reactions to certain disease. However, if we start introducing Intelligent Design, we would be preaching God in our science classroom. Everyone has a right to their own religion and system of beliefs, but also the right to education and knowledge; however, there is a difference between forcing religion on someone and teaching science in class.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Should Religion be taught in schools?


Question: Religion is a practice someone chooses to follow, intelligent design is a religious theory hiding under different words. Who gets to decide that religion be taught at a school and not as a choice?
A religion is a practice someone chooses to follow, a religion shouldn't be forced upon a person if they do not believe or want to follow the religion. It is well known that many people believe in Intelligent Design. They like to say that a "designer" is the creater. Who is the designer? Now most people that do not believe in intelligent design would say that the designer is God; the believers dont want to classify the creator as god because then it is a religious view and therefore could not be taught in schools. But because they have changed the words and meanings a bit it could be taught. Who gets to decide that religion be taught at a school not as a choice? Because it is basically religion talking. It is thought that it should not be taught seeing as practicing a religion is a choice.
The premise of this argument would be that intelligent design is a religious theory hiding under different words. While the conclusion would be that religion is a practice someone chooses to follow.
This would be a Deductive Argument. This is because the premise is true which would mean that the conclusion would have to be true. Which means we have a valid argument. Intelligent Design should not be taught in schools because that would be almost forcing someone to believe a religion that is not what they believe in. Although some people might not agree with Evolution, but unlike intelligent design it has much more evidence that makes sense and can be explained. If someone equates teaching evolution with forced belief I would say to them that the subjects aren't very similar. This is because we have proof of evolution. Some people may not believe in evolution and complain that, that is like forcing them to believe; but its not like they are being lied to. What is being taught is proved and is true. Students in high school choose what they want to believe. Just because its being taught doesn't mean they will believe it. For the reasons above this is why intelligent design (based on religious views) should not be taught in schools.